Categories
ownership

the Sixth Sense

Dog Gear of the Year

A review of the best dog product I found this year
spaniel dog in kitchen wearing blue winter jacket, dog gear of the year blog

Sometimes we discover a product when we think ‘where you been all my (dog’s) life?!’ and this happened to me this year. Here is an honest, unprompted review of it, as well as an honourable mention for some other things I use with a longer track-record. Please note, I have no affiliations and receive no incentives with any products mentioned. So, without further ado, let’s dive in with my Dog Gear of the Year!

1. Gear of the Year winner! Pawfect4Pets Waterproof Dog Jacket with Harness

I explored the question of whether you should invest in a dog coat in an earlier blog post (November 2022). For those with puppies, senior dogs, smaller or slim breeds, or arguably most dogs in the winter months, it can be a good idea. If you are looking around for one, this is a great coat.

With my adult springer, who feels the cold, I felt I had never really solved the issue of having a jacket appropriate for him. I use a raincoat for him for downpours when we just have to get from A to B, and also a thermal coat just for very cold temperatures on a walk. Neither can handle the other job, and I was never completely happy with the job they did do. This Pawfect4Pets jacket solved all our problems in one go. Although it hasn’t been especially cold or wet so far this autumn, we have already tested it three times and the results have been very encouraging.

Here is what I like about it:
  • It appears very well made, with quality stitching and fabrics for the price.
  • It is very, very reasonably priced, proof that you can still buy high-quality products for your dog on a budget, if you shop around.
  • It provides both warmth with a padded soft fleece inner lining and a ‘waterproof’ shell outer layer.
  • Every dog shape and size is different, but I finally found a coat that actually fits my dog: the front leg openings and chest are not too tight, and the top reaches almost all the way down his back to his tail. The result is compact and snug without being too tight, so allowing freedom of movement.
  • Easy on-off with a zipper so your dog can step into it – nothing has to go over their head.
  • It’s a handsome design – it actually looks good rather than awkward and comes with a good range of colour choices.
  • It’s light, breathable, machine-washable, and air-dries quickly.
  • And for me the star inclusion: a built-in, fully adjustable harness with reflecting stitching, sewn around the outside of the jacket.

For the two of us, it ticks every box. My dog actually seems to enjoy wearing it, which never used to happen!

The problem it solves

So many pet products try to invent a problem that doesn’t really exist. This is not the case with the Pawfect4Pets Waterproof Dog Jacket. It genuinely addresses a need. For me the biggest problem it fixes is where to attach the lead so your dog is both safe and comfortable when wearing a coat. Attaching the lead to a collar or a chest clip of a harness inevitably means pulling the front of the coat down. If there is an opening on the back, it would rarely coincide with where the harness’s back clip sits. Both would involve a degree of ‘faff’ as well. Now I simply clip the lead onto the coat and away we go.

Safety and quality of construction are my highest priorities, and the quality of the sewing looks high and the material appears strong. The all-important adjustable clips fit tightly and have a re-assuring click sound when engaged.

A few things to note

I cannot comment on durability as I have not owned it for long. That said, I used to do some training walks with another dog who had worn one of these for several years, and it was always reliable for us and still going strong.

Describing this as ‘waterproof’ may be a stretch, and no Hydrostatic Head measurement is given. Having tried it in light rain, it certainly kept my dog dry. ‘Water Resistant’ it certainly is.

The lightness of construction has to come at a price. I’m not sure how tear-proof it would prove to be if my dog was in sixth gear diving in and out of hawthorn hedges. But this would be an unlikely scenario in the weather conditions we would be using it.

The sizing is very accurate and with a good range, though I do not think the largest dogs would be accommodated. The sizing goes up to 5XL and my springer (quite tall and long) fits a 4XL with a little room to spare, so I would imagine anything much larger than a golden retriever will be too large for this jacket.

And although I trust the harness construction and strength, I would not solely rely on it if your dog pulls like a train. If that’s the case, you could double-up with a collar. But more recommended would be some training – I am here for just that!

Most likely Uses

For me, the Pawfect4Pets Waterproof Dog Jacket is ideally suited for wintry conditions that are not too extreme. If things were extreme, you might be thinking twice about a walk anyway. But in heavy rain I would still opt for a dedicated raincoat. Otherwise, I can envisage a wide range of conditions that this coat is ideally suited for:

  • Cold conditions from dry to windy to light snow
  • Cold, squally drizzle or light rain
  • Damp, humid (cold), muddy conditions
  • Mist, fog, ‘wet air’
  • In other words, storms excepted, winter!

Overall the Pawfect4Pets Waterproof Dog Jacket provides good all-round protection against the elements, namely cold, wind and rain. And an easy, safe, flexible one-stop solution instead of using multiple items of gear to go for a walk. Hi-5 those paws!

Here is the product page:

Waterproof Dog Jacket with Harness | Pawfect4Pets

And my original post about dog coats generally:

Does my dog need a coat? – Blog – Dog Citizen | Eastside Tails

2. Honourable Mentions

I intend to review all of these together in more detail in a future post. They are all items my dog has used for many years and have proved reliable for us. So, in no particular order, here is a brief mention…

  • Ruffwear Front Range harness. Not cheap, but for me, still the gold standard in strong, durable, light, comfortable, and easy on-off harnesses. Won’t suit every dog but a great all-rounder.
  • PcEo Tilar LED Light Up Dog Collar. Inexpensive, long-charge and reliable brightly lit collar for dark walks.
  • Swauswauk Dog Seat Belt. Heavy duty, anti-twist, anti-shock seat belt with locking rotation carabiner and additional isofix attachment.
  • Fat Face Danish Design Dog Snug Bed. Really plush and soft, fun patterns, made from recycled materials and still available for a very reasonable price. Has kept its shape over many years.

Feel free to drop me a comment about a piece of dog gear you couldn’t live without!

Disclaimer: I have no affiliations and receive no incentives with any of these products. Nor does my endorsement come with any guarantee regarding any product. Nor do I accept any responsibility or liability regarding any product mentioned.

Categories
ownership

the Sixth Sense

Moving house with your dog

How to make the transition for them less traumatic
springer spaniel dog at home looking out of window moving house with your dog blog

Having recently moved house myself, I thought it might be helpful to share a few things about my own experiences with my dog. It’s a big topic so let’s dive straight in and take a closer look at moving house with your dog. And how we can make the transition for them less traumatic!

The first, most important thing we should always remember is:

Dogs love routine and can be stressed with big changes.

This will be our ‘mantra’. It may seem obvious but it can be easy to overlook. If we always keep our mantra in mind, specific scenarios with a house move can always be made less traumatic for our dogs.

1. Are you moving within the same area?

If you are moving locally, it stands to reason that taking your dog outside to the same places they are currently familiar with will greatly benefit them. Of course you will want to explore the newer areas closer to your new home, but in the early days try and balance this with returning to their older, favourite haunts too. If time permits, try walking your dog around your new neighbourhood before you actually move, to help ease them into their new environment. Or if your walk won’t be changing at all, you are in luck!

2. If you are moving much further away

This was the case with us. Before we put an offer on the new house, we arranged to visit the surrounding area with Woody and went for a long walk. It was really useful to gauge his reaction to the area, and to see if there were any hidden surprises too. In our case, it was a rural area, so the presence and location of livestock was important. As was the wildlife – adders – bad, pheasants – good!

But think about any wildlife impacts on your dog’s wellbeing. If it’s an urban area, are there any differences, such as more traffic or being closer to more people and other dogs? I think you have a sharper awareness of benefits and potential dangers when you are actually on the walk with your dog. So this was an invaluable experience for us. I realise this might not be possible to do, but try to at least to research the area from your dog’s perspective, or ask your vendors about it.

3. Before the move itself

This is the crucial bit! With Woody, it was the weeks leading up to the move that he found more stressful than the move itself. The big day is usually what everyone talks about, but try not to underestimate the emotional upheaval associated with packing boxes. Remember, your dog does not understand what is actually going on, only that all the objects familiar to them are being removed from sight or put in a different place. Their home is changing, no longer a constant, and being eroded. You seem stressed and rushed. Boxes piled high can create a claustrophobic anxiety too.

Remember our mantra, and there are little things you can do to mitigate the added stress:

  • Try to keep calm yourself when you are packing. This includes not doing everything too quickly, panicky or involving sudden loud noises. This can be difficult to do, without realising.
  • I would advise against shielding your dog from what’s going on by keeping them in a separate room – if they want to be with you, let them. But do encourage them onto their bed or to be in their ‘safe space’, wherever that is.
  • When you take short breaks, don’t forget your dog, give them some attention!
  • As much as you can, keep boxes away from your dog’s most important spaces: feeding stations and beds especially.
  • The things in these spaces should be the very last things to move or pack – literally when you are leaving on the day.
4. On the big day

As you can imagine there is a lot of scope for extreme canine stress: lots of ‘strangers’ invading every possible space in the home, lots of noise and upheaval. It’s really important to start the day with their normal routine: if this means a walk and breakfast, even if it has to be much earlier than normal, then so be it.

There are two paths you can take here: the first is having your dog stay with someone else they are familiar with for a few hours. This might be the ‘lesser of two evils’ if your dog is especially territorial or reactive. If you do this though, it’s important to return them to the (now empty) house before you all set off. Try and make it a positive but low key experience, just for a few minutes. Let them see and sniff every room if that’s what they want to do. Remember your dog is trying to understand a situation completely new to them. Then you are good to go.

The second is more preferable if it’s at all practical: to keep your dog with you. This is because at a time of the greatest emotional upheaval, being separated from you would otherwise add to the stress. The common advice here is to try to keep your dog in their ‘safe space’ for the duration of the physical move. We adapted this as it’s nearly impossible to achieve when the moving team is working throughout the house.

What we did was allow Woody to meet and greet the moving team on arrival (with each of their permission), and with a generous application of treats to maintain the positive experience.

Once the first room was cleared, we settled him on his bed in that room with a favourite chew, so he had something he couldn’t resist to concentrate on. The room was ideal because he could see a lot of what was going on, but without being in a high traffic area. We kept the door open: don’t invite anxiety or frustration with a closed door. But if you are on your own, you could consider using a gate or tethering as long as your dog is already used to this. After a quick, cheerful ‘inspection’ when they had gone, that was it!

5. Moving In

This had similar challenges, but remember now there are no familiar (comforting) spaces for your dog. Hopefully the excitement of a new environment will over-ride any underlying stress. Normally, you should arrive at the new place ahead of the moving team. This is the perfect time for your dog to familiarise themselves with their new surroundings:

  • Make sure you have their bed and water bowl before you even put the key in the door. These are the first things to put down once inside. Choose a low traffic area for both.
  • Allow them to investigate every room and outdoor space if you have one. It’s a good idea to do this on-lead.
  • Once the moving team arrives, reverse the same procedure for moving out!
6. Settling In

Remembering our mantra, try and keep their routines the same. In many ways you have a ‘clean slate’ so don’t take your dog’s previous behavioural habits for granted. Keep experiences positive, but don’t be afraid to gently change things if they no longer seem to work in the new environment.

I’m not a fan of putting a number on how long it takes a dog to settle in – every dog is different. In our case, Woody was ‘on holiday’ for two weeks, withdrew into himself for the third week, then seemed to be fine. It’s natural for a dog to feel ‘shock’ after a few weeks. It’s important not to overcompensate during this time and ‘reward’ their anxiety, but gently helping them along by making them comfortable and feeling safe is crucial for a hopefully quick recovery.

If you have had a different experience moving home, or have any questions before you do so, I would love to hear from you!

Categories
ownership

Eastside Tails

A Dog’s Set of Needs

Allowing your dog to reach their full potential
alert pointer dog in field looking up

It’s an old cliché in dog training, but sometimes we try to run before we can walk. A lot of my recent work has been with puppies and adopted dogs. In both cases it struck me how similar our priorities for these can be. We need to address some basic needs for our dog before we worry about useful-to-have things.

To help myself as much as much as you, I have mapped out a list of priorities. With a nod to Maslow’s Hierarchy, I am calling it a Set of Needs. The first category does sit above all others, but frankly Levels Two and Three that follow are equal in value, to form a set. By addressing each one, it might help you allow your dog to reach their full potential.

Level 1
a dog's set of needs blog level one set of needs graphic

Level One is about survival. If any one of these are not fulfilled we are in trouble. The Safety aspect can be an overlooked one though. If our dog can escape the confines of their household, even just the once, is not secured in a car, or can lunge on the lead into a road, we need to revisit this urgently!

Level 2A
a dog's set of needs blog level two A set of needs graphic

Level Two A again addresses physical needs once we have Level One covered. And already we have the possibility of training appearing here. Sometimes regular exercise, appropriate to our dog’s breed, health and age is not always possible if there are behaviour constraints or control issues. And sometimes it’s not obvious what amount of exercise is appropriate: it can sometimes be too much in the case of puppies or senior dogs. Long walks are not a given here. But we should strive to do the best we can to get this one right. And keeping their (and our) environment comfortable is not only good for well-being, but obviously important for health.

Level 2B
a dog's set of needs blog level two B set of needs graphic

Level Two B is where a lot of training and behaviour work can apply. But with nurture, this can sometimes get by-passed, especially if we have a busy life. And for well-being, to feel safe is a different beast from being safe. If your dog can truly settle, and even dream, it’s a good sign.

Level 3
a dog's set of needs blog level three set of needs graphic

Level Three contains just as important elements, although we could say that breed-related fulfilment is sometimes a luxury or even not desirable. Dogs bred to chase prey, for example, is a tricky one, but training aside, those zoomies in the garden can have an important role. And in terms of feeling part of a pack, if you are on your own, this can absolutely be just the two of you.

Finally, the Dignity aspect of this level is really important. As sentient beings, dogs feel pride and satisfaction as well as more primal feelings. Perhaps even empathy. I truly believe that if we use aversion with a dog, even ‘mild’ on the scale such as pulling them down from something, their loss of dignity in those moments hurts them emotionally. It damages their confidence, as well as eroding their trust in us. But we can also passively dent their pride. If they have difficulty negotiating a step or getting down from a car, let’s help them out. Let’s treat them with the respect we expect ourselves!

And there we have it. Our Set of Needs! I would be grateful to hear from anyone who feels I have missed out something obvious!

Categories
training

Eastside Tails

Reactivity: when do we settle for what we have?

And embrace our dog for what they are
path in woodland in winter at sunset reactivity when do we settle for what we have blog

I’m writing this during the most prolonged spell of rain that I can remember. Us dog people are acutely attuned to the seasons and the weather and whatever the records say, for me this is the wettest it’s been in living memory. And just walking for our daily exercise is a challenge. Also funny. As a spaniel dad I let out a wistful sigh as my training-walk imposing Rottweiler (larger than average) tippy-toed so balletically around each puddle! But instantly he had my attention for other reasons as we saw another dog approach. It was cold and wet, but I am not giving up on you. Not today. Remember the drill. But when do we settle for what we have?

When does training stop?

This is a question I often get asked in different ways when we begin a journey. Especially when we are talking about more complex behavioural issues that address emotional response and reactivity. The clichéd answer is never, but I’m not so sure that is right. And what does such an answer do for our own motivation? I just want my dog to be a dog!

The best answer I can give is that the training itself is something I am sharing first with the other human(s) in the pack – we are learning together and from each other. And yes, this is a finite process, of course. What shouldn’t ever stop is reinforcement. Training is work. Reinforcement then becomes simply second-nature. And because we have done our training, reinforcement is just part of the drill – it’s how we do things now. This is not only calming for our dog, it’s calming for us too.

An animal in a human world

We set the bar very high for our dogs. Yes they are ‘domesticated’ compared with their wild ancestors. But we are still dealing with an animal whose brain is wired differently from ours’. And we expect them to fit in flawlessly with our (frankly sometimes weird!) customs and routines. Square peg and round hole springs to mind! And if our dogs don’t seamlessly do this – even with a lot of training – we can feel they are somehow flawed, or we blame ourselves for letting our dog down.

This is why it’s so important to adapt our mindset sympathetically to how our dog perceives our world. It’s their world too, but we are the ones who have imposed the rules. So when we are talking about an aggressive or reactive dog, we are talking about a dog who is not coping with some things in this world and is stressed. More often than not that dog might be a lovely and affectionate family dog at home. It doesn’t mean they are somehow ‘bi-polar’. It means they are always that same, beautiful being, but making the wrong decision. So it’s on us to try and help them feel less stressed and to cope in a better way.

When things go very wrong

When we talk about reactivity there are different scales. At the lower end of the spectrum we might have already tried some training. We make good progress, only for us to have a really bad day. It’s easy to feel all the effort we put in was for nothing, but that is exactly the time to dig in, reset, and keep reminding our dog about the better decision they can make. I’m not giving up on you. Not today.

At the other end of the scale situations can be much more urgent and extreme. But nothing saddens me more than a dog who is euthanised before they and their owners have even tried some rehabilitation training. In these circumstances the dog’s life has been shaped this way by poor human decisions throughout its desperately sad life. To be abused by its original owners perhaps, then rehomed into an inappropriate situation, maybe. A dog deserves at least a chance.

The best gift we can give them

…is a chance. A chance to cope better. This is what good training can do. So when we do try, that is a wonderful, amazing thing to do. And always we can make a positive difference. How far we get of course depends on a lot of things: early socialisation and the dog’s history and current age in particular. It has little to do with intelligence and ability (of either of us). We can often overcome an issue completely, or at least we can always make an improvement.

And if we try – we mustn’t feel guilty or blame ourselves for our dog not being perfect. When I assess a troubled dog I love seeing the parents’ faces brighten when I genuinely point out all the positive traits about their dog. Things they know but are relived that someone else can see too. And in the end if we can’t quite reach the heights we dream of, think of how much worse things were.

If our dog is stressed when they see another dog, we can adapt our routines and routes. Concentrate on the things they love. That’s us by the way. Engagement with us. And it can be things like sniffing or spotting birds. Do all these things. This is what our dog is telling us they love. And we can always, always reinforce a calmer behaviour around things they don’t love so much. If our dog can’t quite overcome that final hurdle, we are still making a positive difference if we engage them to look at us or pop them a nice treat if they are calm when they see something that previously caused an eruption. We are making something stressful more pleasant, and keeping you calmer too.

So we never give up on them. We have done the training. We might have settled for what we have. But we never stop reinforcing. So we know the drill. It’s part of our life. Let’s embrace our dog and all their faults. Afterall, we are hardly faultless either!

That Rottweiler by the way is called Jimbo. When he looks at me, and I can tell you that’s a nice moment, who do I see? Do I see a breed? Do I see problems? No. I see Jimbo.

Categories
ownership

Eastside Tails

Woody & the Leaf

The small moments that carry meaning
large tree and dog in countryside in autumn woody and the leaf blog

As the year gradually draws to a close and a new one is around the corner, it’s a time for reflection. All those dogs I am fortunate enough to learn from. But this time of year in particular I often think about the dogs who were adopted and given a second (or third) chance in life. Often they are not socialised and certainly have little training. And for some, just the experience of being outside beyond the confines of where they once lived is a new experience. This opportunity, to just experience, and to do this together with them, is a privilege for us. They are special moments. And it reminds me of one I had with years ago with my dog when he was a puppy, and it stayed with me ever since. I will call it Woody and the Leaf.

What brought me full circle to remembering Woody & the Leaf were some of the heart-warming tales of those adopted dogs I worked with this year – though often with heart-breaking beginnings. There was a little mutt who was kept in a crate in an outbuilding without any electricity. So when it was dark and cold….it was dark and cold. He was saved. And the fact that this little chap now celebrates life every day in his new home is a testament not only to the kindness of his human adopters, but also to this fella’s amazing will to survive. And the will to love and be loved. He’s taken to the training too! Sure, some things are going to take a long time, but even if time stood still now, what a happy ending.

Then there was the dog who was a forced breeding ‘machine’ and, as far as we could tell, never, ever, let outside the boundaries of her previous ‘home’. With her rescue came some needed medical care, but now she is okay. More than okay. She is safe and happy. And revelling in life with her new human mum. My training always adapts to these dogs’ histories. We don’t ask for a Sit with her, because of physical issues. As long as she is comfortable, we can still reward her for a good behaviour. She likes a treat! We’ll call her Sophie.

Every day brought a new experience for Sophie, and her new owner relished in this. Once she sent me a video of the first time (we think) Sophie saw a cat. They were in a stationary car at the time, with the cat sitting on a fence looking at them, and her owner captured on video the look of Sophie’s curiosity and wonder. We think! But actually it doesn’t matter what we think. It’s what we feel together. What we experience. On the video her owner started laughing, and Sophie barked once as if to join in.

You see, it’s about the small things. It was a small moment but one that carried huge meaning. Sophie was seeing something for the first time and processing it. We want to keep this being a positive experience, but a natural one too. We won’t want to try too hard. Just to experience the moment, and whatever that brings. Being together. Bonding. Sophie’s look of wonderment…

Of course with young puppies, we have a blank canvas with these moments – almost everything is new. Savour these moments. Do it together. But it can be with a dog of any age, and it doesn’t have to be something new. It’s just that moment when they process something that carries meaning for them. Your dog could be much older and even not seeing or hearing well: It can be about touch or smell too. That moment a warm towel goes around them to dry them off, or an especially riveting scent!

Even if a dog is scared of certain things and reactive, we can still enjoy looking at and processing things, as long as we are both together in our safe bubble, from far enough away. Or, yes, it can just be something they will have heard a thousand times before, but this one time their curiosity is piqued. When we’re training sometimes an owner will ask me what their dog is thinking at that moment. Often there isn’t an answer. “I don’t know” I might say, “but it’s nice just wondering, isn’t it?” Revel in the mystery.

These moments are a privilege for us, and are hard to convey in words and so it is with Woody & the Leaf, but I will try. He was a puppy and we were in the garden on an autumn day. I don’t know, probably waiting for that wee. Naturally, he was distracted with everything around him. It was very quiet but there was a breeze. Then suddenly something broke his concentration. It was a leaf falling from a tree. The breeze was perfectly swaying and buffeting it gently on its slow journey downwards. Woody was tilting his head and watching it. As it touched the ground, he still studied it. Then looked up at the sky. “I know”, I said.

*********

I would like to wish all my readers and friends a Happy Christmas and best wishes for the New Year!

Categories
ownership

Eastside Tails

Can dogs feel empathy?

Can they understand and share our feelings?
dog looking up to human showing bond dogs and empathy blog

Dogs, as we all know, are very good at picking on our emotional temperature. I am sure you can imagine countless examples. If a person is nervous with our dog, our dog can become equally cautious. Or if we are excited, our dog is usually more than happy to join in! If we are ill or hurting, most dog owners will swear their dog is sympathetic to our condition – showing a variety of displacement behaviours. So what’s going on here? Some psychologists and behaviourists maintain this is something called emotional contagion. This implies a dog does respond to our feelings, but without properly understanding them. Simply a good, bad or neutral scale. But can dogs feel empathy ?

Defining Empathy

Defining a term is often easier if we first look at what it isn’t, and we should differentiate it from sympathy. Sympathy is when we do share an emotional connection with someone else’s experience or feeling. But there remains a certain detachment. Empathy is something on a much higher level. It implies an actual understanding of those feelings, and the ability to imagine ourselves in the other being’s emotional skin. It’s much more immersive. It implies the ability to differentiate from self and other. So we are setting the bar quite high, here.

My training is based on an empathic approach – ‘Be Dog’ if you like. To re-imagine ourselves into how a dog truly thinks and feels. So it’s important! But I am curious about the level at which a dog can reciprocate this. Because training is as much about engaging with feelings as it is about auto-responses and simply doing things.

First level biological senses

I got to thinking about this topic from a recent experience. I was laid up with an illness and many of you will recognise my dog’s behaviour with this situation. He stuck by me. He was much closer, more of the time. Now, there are other things going on here. Specifically with illness, there are obviously physical changes in the body.  Where these are not immediately obvious to our appearance, from our dog’s point of view, we are still walking around with a big flag. We smell different! Dogs have even been trained to detect certain illnesses with their nose. (I still marvel at this!) But without question, my dog probably knew I had a lurgy well before I showed physical symptoms.

Was his emotional reaction to be closer to me an empathic one though? Sure, there may be other things going on.

Dad is on the sofa during the day. This is weird, I better stay close. Not sure what’s going on. Or…This is nice. He’s not working, it’s good to hang out together. And so on. But most dog parents will tell you, they know, and there is a lot more going on, because we can feel their emotional connection to us.

The mirror test

Some debunk the idea that dogs can feel empathy and distinguish between self and other by using the mirror as an example. But I think this is too crude, and also inconsistent. Most dogs do not seem to react to their reflection in the mirror. A few do though, either displaying prolonged curiosity, or excitement, or even animosity (a belief there is another dog there, or a frustration at not understanding?). But we can never be certain what’s going on in their mind when they see themselves. We could even argue that the majority response of ‘not interested’ means they know exactly what they are seeing, it’s no big deal. Vanity is certainly a concept alien to dogs!

What does the science say?

There have been many studies about this, and they are divided over whether dogs can feel empathy. Because we never know for sure of course. But so many of these studies do hint at the possibility of dogs feeling empathy. Bond Tests (measuring the degree of attachment a dog has to their parent) demonstrate dogs will act with urgency if they feel their owner is in distress. This is a good starting point: emotional contagion for sure. Can we go to a higher level?

For me, one of the most telling studies was by a pair of psychologists. In this experiment, dogs were observed individually in the presence of their parent and also a stranger. The two humans would take turns with different vocalisations, mimicking different emotional levels, such as talking, singing or crying. When the stranger pretended to cry, most of the dogs showed a concern for them. Approaching them, and even licking or muzzling them.

If we are talking about only emotional contagion, we would expect the dogs to possibly mimic the stranger’s behaviour, but approach their owner instead, for comfort. The fact that most chose to try and comfort the stranger instead, suggests evidence of empathic concern.

Mystery and wonder

Maybe some questions can never be answered. But in one sense, the mystery and wonder of dogs’ complex emotional make-up is what is so meaningful to us, rather than how we define truth or fact. I think the answer to the question is Yes. But whatever we believe, embrace the fact that our dog is probably understanding our emotions more than we sometimes give them credit for!